Traditional Marketing Methods Die Hard: What’s Old Is New Again

Eric Siu

It looks like traditional marketing methods die hard. Marketers everywhere are returning to older tactics and strategies that seemingly fizzled out and yet they’re seeing success with them once again.

Agencies like Single Grain and NP Digital have always been future-first media companies, but sometimes we surprise ourselves when we manage to boost our clients’ leads and sales through more traditional marketing strategies.

While AI and machine learning can streamline and quicken content production, they also bring to light issues of authenticity and quality. The flood of AI-generated content across the web has saturated the market with duplicative and superficial material, creating an overly competitive space and, worse, apathy and disdain from users.

In this post, we’ll note some observations about traditional marketing methods that will counteract the sea of AI mumbo-jumbo and can actually help you move the needle in your marketing campaigns this year.

Kim Cooper

Director of Marketing, Amazon Alexa

Single Grain enables us to increase our impact without increasing our headcount

Help Me Improve My Marketing Campaigns

Direct Mail: An Old-School Approach with New-Age Potential

Direct mail is one of the oldest tricks in the playbook, and it still has a place in modern marketing. It really comes down to the way people want to consume their media. And when they’re overloaded with digital ads and notifications through their phones and computers, it can be refreshing to hold a tangible piece of mail.

Believe it or not, there’s also a portion of people who still aren’t all that connected to digital media. For instance, affluent individuals aged 55 and above, who may not be as engaged online, respond well to high-quality, direct mail pieces, even saying that direct mail content will win their attention over digital media:

So keep this in mind:

The direct mail approach is still really potent in local marketing strategies aimed at wealthy communities.

When aiming to engage affluent audiences, the method of delivery can significantly impact the perceived value of your message. Sending materials via premium services like FedEx or UPS can elevate the recipient’s experience, imbuing your communication with a sense of importance and exclusivity.

It’s a strategic reminder that in marketing, every detail matters, and perception can significantly influence effectiveness. But it’s not just about sending letters and fliers anymore, it’s about crafting personalized, tactile connections in an increasingly impersonal digital world.

Our guess is that more and more businesses and agencies will start prioritizing direct mail as a subversive tactic to gain people’s attention outside of the digital playing field.

Privacy Regulations Are Forcing Marketers to Do More With Less

Let’s back up for a second (or fast-forward?). The advent of ethical correctness in digital media has drastically altered the way businesses will engage with their customers this year and beyond.

As digital environments and privacy concerns have grown, so has the public’s behavior when it comes to tracking and data collection in marketing. Techniques that once delivered remarkable outcomes (because they were easier to track) are getting more complicated and, in more cases now, incredibly vague to discern.

Let’s take a quick look at two examples:

Targeted Online Advertising

In the past, marketers could easily track users’ online activities and preferences through cookies and third-party data, enabling highly personalized and effective advertising campaigns. However, with the rise of data privacy concerns and regulations like GDPR in Europe and CCPA in California, coupled with tech companies like Apple implementing stricter privacy controls, the ability to track and target users has become significantly more challenging.

Marketers now need to find new strategies for reaching their audience without relying on the extensive data previously available to them.

Email Marketing

It was once relatively straightforward to track open rates, click-through rates and conversions from email campaigns, thanks to technologies that allowed for detailed monitoring of user interactions with emails. But privacy-focused changes, such as Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection, which prevents senders from using invisible pixels to collect information about the user, have made it harder to gauge the effectiveness of email campaigns.

Marketers have had to adapt by focusing more on the quality of content and engagement rather than relying heavily on tracking metrics.

So what’s to be done?

Here are some tips to navigate the privacy-first climate of digital marketing:

Adopt a Privacy-First Approach: With digital privacy concerns on the rise, make sure your marketing tactics are transparent and secure.
Prioritize User Experience: Always look for ways to simplify and enhance the user journey, making interactions as seamless as possible. If the user is happy, they’ll be more likely to share their data with you voluntarily.
Stay Informed on Privacy Trends: This is a given, but it will set apart the so-so marketers from the ones at the top of their game. As consumer sensitivity towards privacy increases, be certain that your marketing strategies respect and reflect these concerns.
Iterate like Crazy: Regularly test different aspects of your marketing strategy to identify what works best and why (this includes a combination of digital and traditional tactics).
Listen to Your Audience: Use customer feedback as a crucial input for refining and adjusting your marketing approaches.
Monitor Conversion Trends: Keep an eye on how conversion rates fluctuate over time to gauge the effectiveness of your strategies. This is especially crucial when evaluating the marketing results you garnered in the last couple years compared to this year when third-party cookie depreciation will finally take effect.

If you apply these tips to your own marketing philosophy and approach, you’ll undoubtedly be way ahead of the game in 2024.

The Intersection of Old and New: Maximizing Value

The resurgence of newsletters highlights a critical aspect of marketing — maximizing value through understanding and innovation.

An admittedly aging tactic, newsletters have experienced a renaissance, reminding us of their potency in fostering direct relationships with consumers. But instead of cluttering them with ads, newsletters today should be completely focused on delivering value to the recipients (your prospects). From there, you’ll naturally encourage affinity to your brand, leading to more engaged audiences and, ultimately, their taking a desired action.

Newsletters are just one example, though. It’s essential to challenge the status quo and not take for granted the effectiveness of prevailing marketing trends, or just anything that’s being thrown around on the internet.

Here’s a quick list of the most popular traditional marketing methods you can try out. Again, not all of these may be applicable to your brand, so it’s up to you to decide which one(s) will likely give you the best value for your time:

Direct mail
Advertising
Billboards
Broadcasting
Event marketing
Telemarketing
Broadcast marketing
Referrals & referral marketing
Cold calling
Print
Sales
Direct marketing
Email marketing
Handouts
Newspaper or magazine ads
Phone calls

Yes, it’s wise to entertain all your options, including experimental strategies, but what works for one brand may not work for another, and even proven strategies can falter. So stay cautious, and iterate constantly.

Conclusion: Blending Tradition with Innovation

Taking a look at the differences between traditional marketing methods and modern innovations, it’s clear that the key to enduring success lies in a finely seasoned blend.

Understanding your industry, audience and strategies’ temporal effectiveness is paramount. The evolution of marketing is a testament to its foundational principle: Connect with your audience in the most effective, authentic way possible, irrespective of the medium.

The journey from traditional to digital and back to traditional just goes to show the nature of marketing trends and the perennial quest for relevance and connection in an ever-changing market. Even now, more and more people are catching on to how AI-derived marketing content is shallow when compared to more soul-filled marketing material.

Because of that, it’s no wonder that people are gravitating back to old-school marketing techniques. But be ready, because AI certainly isn’t going anywhere, and it’s only going to get better at mimicking genuine human creativity.